The influence of the e-transport increase on the journey insurance coverage sphere – ITIJ


“E-bikes and e-scooters are rising in popularity in vacationer locations around the globe, and it is very important know if you’re coated by your journey insurance coverage earlier than you experience,” mentioned Kasara Barto, a spokesperson for Squaremouth, a US-based journey insurance coverage comparability web site.

The e-scooter rental sector has clearly reached important mass and is not going away

In January 2019, the European Parliament determined towards classifying electrical bikes as motor autos as a part of a brand new Motor Insurance coverage Directive, a transfer that might have made full motor insurance coverage together with third-party legal responsibility cowl obligatory for e-cyclists. The choice was welcomed by producers and biking lobbyists, who claimed it will deter customers from shopping for right into a clear, inexperienced and revolutionary type of transport.

Older riders

Are e-bikes inherently riskier to riders (and third events) than standard bicycles? Some statistics appear to counsel they’re, and that older cyclists could also be a larger danger, partly maybe as a result of e-bikes are hottest with the older technology of riders.

One nationwide British bike vendor, Halfords, says that 65 per cent of e-bike consumers are over 55 years previous, whereas one in 4 Dutch cyclists concerned in deadly bike accidents had been using e-bikes, based on the official Centraal Bureau voor de Statistiek (Statistics Netherlands). Three out of 4 of these killed had been males over 65. Fatalities involving e-bikes doubled in 2017, based on Statistics Netherlands.     

E-bikes are hottest with the older technology of riders

Within the US, the Nationwide Park Service has controversially introduced that it’ll open up cycle trails to e-bikes with a high velocity of 28 mph as a part of the Trump administration’s ongoing commercialisation of America’s nationwide parks. Within the UK, (aside from Northern Eire), anybody over 14 could legally experience an e-bike on or off-road, although not on the sidewalk – a rule that’s usually damaged, as it’s by unpowered cyclists – and e-bikes don’t require insurance coverage or registration. In Northern Eire, nevertheless, e-bikes are handled as mopeds and should be licensed, registered, taxed and insured.  

The European Fee had argued that e-bikes and electrical scooters (additionally referred to as private gentle electrical autos or PLEVs) needs to be outlined as ‘new kinds of electrical motor autos’ and so had been already throughout the scope of the EU Motor Insurance coverage Directive, including that such autos have the potential to trigger accidents, whose victims want safety and swift reimbursement.


In the meantime, the worldwide increase in short-term electrical scooter rental in cities around the globe is one other potential trigger for concern. Corporations like US-based Chicken, arguably the most important participant within the sphere, and its rival Lime, lease e-scooters from a number of shops in standard US and European metropolis locations for as little as €10 per hour. Lime, which already operates in round 60 US cities, is predicted to have a presence in as much as 30 European cities quickly, and European startups like Berlin-based Tier, lively in 40 cities throughout 12 nations, and Stockholm-based Voi, current in round 25 European cities, are additionally in rivalry. The e-scooter rental sector has clearly reached important mass and is not going away.

Regulation and enforcement differ extensively from nation to nation and even metropolis to metropolis. The place e-scooter rental is already on supply, it’s typically a ‘dockless’, paperwork-free course of (in contrast to standard automobile rental operations). Scooters are fitted with GPS trackers, and renters decide up, unlock, pay for, and drop off autos wherever they select, utilizing an app on their cell machine. Rental corporations like Lime do publish security tips on their web sites, however depart it as much as purchasers to abide by them. 

“Every [US] state has totally different guidelines and laws concerning e-scooters,” identified Dale Q. Williams, Chief Working Officer of, a US-based on-line insurance coverage market weblog. “It isn’t required that you’ve got insurance coverage whilst you function one, and e-scooter corporations sometimes received’t cowl you within the occasion of an accident. As well as, your house owner’s insurance coverage normally excludes claims arising out of using motor autos, and your private auto insurance coverage excludes legal responsibility protection for a automobile with fewer than 4 wheels. There’s an opportunity you could be coated beneath your medical insurance coverage in the event you get injured from an accident. Additionally, some private umbrella insurance policies could present protection.”

Williams surmised: “To sum all of it up, though you aren’t required to have e-scooter insurance coverage, it’s definitely in your finest curiosity to have some protection both by private umbrella insurance coverage or third get together protection offered by the e-scooter firm you rented from.”

E-scooter and e-bike rental corporations (similar to Amsterdam’s long-established Black Bikes, an early adopter of e-bikes) usually construct third-party legal responsibility and harm insurance coverage into the rental worth to guard their very own funding. They don’t typically supply wider insurance coverage cowl.

“Travellers do must be conscious that legal responsibility is rarely coated by journey insurance coverage,” defined Squaremouth’s Kasara Barto. “If an accident causes harm to the e-bike, e-scooter or to a different automobile, that harm won’t be coated.”

E-scooter rental corporations (or ‘micromobility corporations’) say they take rider security critically and that they take steps to verify renters are conscious of native street security guidelines. “There is no such thing as a proof in our information that means riders who lease scooters whereas on vacation are extra accident-prone,” mentioned Sarah Seymour, a spokesperson for Lime. Seymour notes that Lime doesn’t promote insurance coverage to renters or make suggestions concerning journey insurance coverage ‘as that is a person resolution’. “Nevertheless,” she provides, “in each market we function in, we abide by the insurance coverage insurance policies required by native legislation. Our insurance coverage meets or exceeds the necessities set forth by native regulators.”

Safety first

Nonetheless, Seymour provides that for no matter purpose folks select to make use of Lime, whether or not it’s as a part of a vacation or just for his or her every day commute, the corporate is dedicated to educating its riders, providing customers security tutorials that should be watched earlier than a person can unlock their first scooter.

As with most new applied sciences, e-bikes have turn out to be less expensive, extra dependable, and extra environment friendly since they appeared available on the market within the 1980s

“We encourage all our riders to adjust to native laws and urge riders to at all times use helmets,” she informed ITIJ. “We invested US$three million within the ‘Respect the Experience’ marketing campaign, the place 140,000 riders thus far have pledged to observe secure using practices.”  

However, the onus remains to be on the person renter, not on the rental firm, to experience safely – and it’s estimated that as few as one in 10 e-scooter riders put on helmets. In 2019, an investigation by US organisation Client Studies, which highlighted accidents involving e-scooter riders in American cities, reported that there have been at the least eight deaths and 1,500 accidents since 2017.

In 2019, following stories of an rising variety of accidents involving e-scooters, the Amsterdam metropolis authorities moved to ban scooters on public cycle paths and restrict their use to roads. Scooter riders may even be required by legislation to put on helmets, which haven’t been obligatory till now. Different Netherlands municipalities are anticipated to observe go well with.

In Madrid (which banned rental scooters from its streets in 2018), privately-owned scooters could also be used on streets, however not on sidewalks or pedestrian zones. France permits e-scooters to be ridden on sidewalks at not more than six kph, or on roads at a most velocity of 25 kph. Within the US, in the meantime, New York Metropolis has banned e-scooters altogether, and riders danger a US$500 positive, however California permits them to be ridden on roads and cycle lanes. In Germany, the utmost permitted velocity on bike paths and roads is 20 kph, and there’s a €30 positive for using on pavements.

Within the UK, e-scooters haven’t beforehand been legally used besides on non-public property. In London, police have reportedly confiscated e-scooters from house owners who used them on roads, sidewalks or cycle paths. In July 2020, nevertheless, the British Authorities modified its stance. Below the brand new guidelines set out by the Division for Transport, native authorities and devolved administrations within the UK can permit or run e-scooter sharing schemes of their areas as a part of 12-month trials. Rental e-scooters can now be used on roads; it is strongly recommended that riders put on helmets. Main e-scooter rental corporations are little doubt salivating on the prospect of the emergence of an enormous new market.

If older e-bike riders could also be a fear for insurers, youthful and fewer accountable scooter riders are already a priority in lots of cities, particularly these with a popularity as ‘get together cities’. In August 2019, native politicians in Munich reportedly demanded that e-scooter using needs to be banned throughout Oktoberfest, the annual beer competition that has turn out to be a magnet for a whole bunch of hundreds of fun-loving millennials, after a variety of e-scooter customers had been charged with using whereas drunk. Issues surrounding irresponsible riders have additionally been voiced in cities as numerous as Amsterdam, Copenhagen , Singapore, and Atlanta.

“Being inebriated or medicine is excluded by all journey insurance coverage insurance policies,” commented Barto of Squaremouth. “If a traveller requires any emergency medical consideration whereas intoxicated, journey insurance coverage won’t cowl it.”

Youthful and fewer accountable scooter riders are already a priority in lots of cities

Typically, although, e-bikes and e-scooters might be coated by an ordinary journey insurance coverage coverage, particularly by way of medical protection for accidents sustained whereas utilizing them, in addition to any pay as you go bills associated to them, she says: “Most insurers think about e-bikes and e-scooters the identical as an ordinary road bike, and may present protection for accidents and even deaths which will happen whereas using.”

If claims regarding e-scooter leases pattern upwards as they turn out to be much more extensively accessible, it is not inconceivable that insurers may rethink their place. For now, although, e-scooter and e-bike renters are not a fear on a par with standard bike and scooter riders in poorly regulated vacation locations.

This text initially appeared in

Challenge 235 | August 2020

Learn Full Challenge

Publishing Particulars

Journey Insurance coverage

four Aug 2020


Robin Gauldie is a contract journalist and a former editor of a variety of journey commerce and specialist publications together with Journey Commerce Gazette Europe, ABTA Journal, Eire 2000 and Local weather Change – Addressing the Problem. He contributes to a number of newspapers and magazines together with The Scotsman and Telegraph Journey and is the creator of greater than 30 journey guidebooks to locations around the globe. He lives in Edinburgh.

Robin has been writing for ITIJ and its Evaluate publications on a contract foundation since 2008, masking a variety of matters that span the worldwide insurance coverage and help sectors. 

READ  Accessible journey placed on maintain by COVID-19 - Coronavirus (COVID-19) - Canada - Mondaq Information Alerts


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here